Question:
Do you believe a 2D RPG for the PC would do well in the shareware market with nice graphics if the gameplay is top notch.
Answer:
Absolutely. If you find the right market, have top notch game play I see no reason why it couldn’t do well. If you have the patience and skill to make it sell, I’m sure it will.
But more important question is – do you believe it could sell?
I don’t know what was the situation in this specific case. It might have been… or might have not.
Is the game producer the one who came up with the idea of the game?